Rating the Rolling Stones [the first 20 years]
For reference, I’m
going to use the U.S. releases as these were the prevalent CD’s until
2002. Note that the U.K. versions of 1965’s
Out Of Our Heads and 1966’s Aftermath
vary greatly [1967’s Between the
Buttons less so] from what the U.S. market was given – like the Beatles,
the Stones’ singles in the U.K. were not put on the album. And like the Beatles
the two countries releases were synched up in 1967, in this case starting with Their Satanic Majesties.
21.
Metamorphosis – As a result of splitting from Allen
Klein at the end of the 60s, Klein’s company ABKCO won control of the Stones
masters from 1962-1969. This dump of 14 outtakes plus a decidedly morbid Heart Of Stone with an organ as the lead
instrument and Out Of Time with strings
is mostly bottom of the barrel dreck. Even the Stones take on Memo From Turner is pretty bad. [The
London Singles Collection uses Jagger’s
first solo single version with Ry Cooder on guitar.] Save your ears and just
get Don’t Lie To Me, I Don’t Know Why, Jiving
Sister Fanny and I’m Going Down
off of Amazon and don’t look back.
20.
Flowers – As noted, [and much as Capitol had done with the
Beatles], the stones US/Canada label London felt free to cut and paste the
Rolling Stones catalog as it was received. In most cases this was to add
whatever singles were out or had just finished their run. Flowers is the second collection of a couple of singles plus songs
pulled from the UK versions of Aftermath
and Between the Buttons. [I
actually would recommend seeking out the UK versions of those two CDs for your
collection.] While it does contain Ruby Tuesday, Have You Seen Your Mother,
Baby and Let’s Spend the Night
Together, you will be getting those on other releases. The only real
necessity here is the folky Sittin’ On A
Fence.
19.
12x5
– unlike the Beatles, who were writing their own songs from the get go, Jagger
and Richards didn’t start writing their own songs until 1964. So the early,
early Stones records are mainly covers. While this can be good if you’re
picking good material, some of the covers here leave something to be desired.
Not so of their takes of Chuck Berry’s Around
and Around and Bobby and Shirley
Woamck’s It’s All Over Now. [The
version of Time Is On My Side here
starts with the organ – and I hate that version.] Jagger and Richards come
through here with the very under rated Good
Times, Bad Times [not to be confused with the Led Zeppelin song with the
same title]. The band jam [credited to Nanker Phelge and names in honor of the
location of Chess Records studio] 2120
South Michigan Avenue is surprisingly funky for English white boys. Bill
Wyman smokes on this track!
18.
The Rolling Stones, Now! – again a lot of covers here.
Stand outs include the 1940 boogie woogie number Down the Road Apiece and Willie Dixon’s Little Red Rooster [a long time favorite of mine]. Mick and Keith
add Heart Of Stone and What A Shame but still a thin record.
17.
It’s Only Rock And Roll – with Keith deep into addiction,
the Micks [Jagger and Taylor] try to soldier on with decidedly mixed results.
The funky Dance Little Sister and Fingerprint File are pretty good. The
title track I’m tired of but it’s a good song. And Time Waits For No One is absolutely stunning, a great showpiece for
Taylor’s guitar playing. Unfortunately, those are about the only highlights and
lack of writing credit for his work led to Taylor exiting the band at the end
of the year.
16.
Aftermath – While this does contain
three of my favorite tracks from this period, Stupid Girl, Lady Jane and Under
My Thumb, the rest of this album just really does nothing for me.
15.
Their Satanic Majesties Request – ah yes, the band’s
acid tinged album. She’s A Rainbow, 2000
Light Years From Home and Citadel
are great tracks. The Lantern is
pretty good. But overall, yeah it’s pretty mediocre. Unless you like a lot of
Mellotron.
14.
Out Of Our Heads
– While the US version adds [I Can’t Get
No] Satisfaction and The Last Time and also contains the hilarious Under Assistant West Coast Promotion Man,
the under rated Spider And the Fly
and Play With Fire, the covers again
slow this collection down.
13.
Emotional Rescue – the Stones second album with Woody is
an okay album. Despite how cringeworthy it is now, the title track was a top 5 US hit. But with songs like Down In the Hole, Let Me Go and She’s So Cold, it’s not terrible like
say It’s Only Rock And Roll.
12.
Goats Head Soup - while I have come to like this a little more over the last couple of
years, coming off of the four albums before this, the Stones were due for a bit
of a “coming down.” Angie is another
song I’m tired of. It does have Doo Doo
Doo Doo Doo (yes that’s the official title) [Heartbreaker], another great track for Mick Taylor in Winter, the fun Silver Train and the evil Dancing
With Mr. D. Again, a good record, just not one I reach for a lot.
11.
Black And Blue – While it holds a special place in my
heart, being the first Stones record I was exposed to, this mishmash is what it
is. I like Hot Stuff, Fool To Cry and
Crazy Mama is a great little gem. But
it’s the semi-autobiographical Memory
Motel that’s the standout track on this album.
10.
The Rolling Stones [aka England’s Newest Hit Makers] – the
debut by the Stones is more memorable that the Beatles [Please Please Me]. Powered along by Muddy Waters’ I Just Want To Make Love To You and I’m A King Bee, Buddy Holly’s Not Fade Away, Nat King Cole’s Route 66 and Chuck Berry’s Carol.
9.
Between the Buttons – London peeling off two tracks to add Let’s Spend the Night Together and Ruby Tuesday actually works to make this
a better record than the UK version. A lot of tracks I dig like Yesterday’s Papers, Connection, My Obsession
and Miss Amanda Jones.
8.
December’s Children [And Everybody’s] – this collection of
tracks released just in time for Christmas in 1965 compiles the single Get Off My Cloud and the rest of the UK
version of Out Of Our Heads. It’s
actually one of my favorites of the early period Rolling Stones.
7.
Through the Past, Darkly [Big Hits, Vol. 2] – You’re going
to need some Rolling Stones compilation to get the two great singles Jumpin’ Jack Flash and Honky Tonk Women [and the good Dandelion]. If you’re just a casual fan
of the band, this record or Hot Rocks
1964 – 1971] will fit the bill.With Hot Rocks, you'll also get 19th Nervous Breakdown, a couple of cuts from Let It Bleed and Sticky Fingers and the positively smoking Get Your Ya Yas version of Midnight Rambler. But you're going to pay double CD prices.
6.
Tattoo You – while this is a compilation of vault tracks from
as far back as 1972 [Waiting On A Friend and
Tops, with Mick Taylor on guitar, not
Ron Wood] side 1 is a lineup of killer rockers, even if I could go a long time
without hearing Start Me Up again.
The 2002 CD version even restore about a minute and a half of the great groove
tune Slave. Side 2 starters Worried About You and Tops are just okay, I always liked the
sweeping tone on Heaven.
5.
Beggar’s Banquet – a similarly critical turning point
for the Stones as Rubber Soul was
for the Beatles this album marks the beginning of a classic period of the
Stones history. The Stones left pop and psychedelics completely behind and dug
back into their roots in blues and country. It was the last album on which
Brian Jones played a major contribution [notably sitar and tanpura on Street Fighting Man and the wonderful
slide guitar part on No Expectations]
and the first of a run of five with producer Jimmy Miller. While I could go a
long, long time without hearing Sympathy
For the Devil again, there’s a great pile of tracks I can enjoy: No Expectations, Parachute Woman, the
extremely fun Jigsaw Puzzle, Street
Fighting Man and the low down Stray Cat Blues.
4.
Some Girls – Ron Wood’s official debut as a full member of the
band [though he was not made a full partner until 1990]. Some Girls is a great recovery from a band that had seemed in free
fall for a couple of years. The songs are short and intensely focused thanks to
Woody’s guitar style meshing with Keith’s into what Keith calls “the fine art
of weaving.**” And the Stones finally redeem themselves for two previous bad
covers of Tempations songs with Just My
Imagination [Running Away With Me]. While one can argue whether certain
songs are now played to death [Miss You]
and how Jagger’s syrupy faux country voice on Far Away Eyes [And Dear Doctor.
And Dead Flowers] gets old after a
few hundred plays, it’s hard to argue with these 10 songs as one of the
strongest Stones albums ever.
3.
Exile On Main Street – while it was not well received in 1972,
this double album has risen to become many people’s “best” Stones album. I am
not one of those people. Still, hitting on 15-16 of 18 tracks is pretty damn
good! This album runs the gamut of basic Stones rockers [All Down the Line, Soul Survivor] to country tinged [Sweet Virginia, one of my favorites, Torn And Frayed] to blues [Slim Harpo’s Shake Your Hips, Robert Johnson’s Stop Breaking Down] to gospel [Let It Loose, Shine A Light]. Also has
two of the best songs the Stones ever laid to tape: Tumbling Dice and Keith’s lead spotlight song Happy.
2.
Let It Bleed – from the opening notes of Gimme Shelter to the last strains of the
London Bach Choir, this is perhaps the quintessential Stones album. It was my
favorite and perhaps sits more of a 1-A [depending on the day] to Sticky Fingers. At times You Can’t Always Get What You Want seems
bloated but you can’t argue with Gimme
Shelter, Love In Vain, the under-rated Live
With Me and Monkey Man.
1.
Sticky Fingers – starting with Brown Sugar [did you know Mick wrote that while in Australia
filming Ned Kelly?] and ending with
the dreamy Moonlight Mile, this is
just an amazing album. Wild Horses is
just one of the most beautiful songs the band has ever done, the outro jam on Can’t You Hear Me Knocking, the hard
driving riff and horns on Bitch, the
Memphis inspired soul of I Got the Blues
and Ry Cooder’s stinging slide work on Sister
Morphine are all just jaw dropping even almost 50 years later. If you
listen closely to the lyrics of Moonlight
Mile, that’s about as personal as you’re gonna get from Mick.
* If you’re going to be
an elitist completist, you’re going to have to get More Hot Rocks [Big Hits and Fazed Cookies] for about 10 songs and probably
still wind up getting half a dozen other compilations to get one or two songs
on each. If you’re THAT into the Stones, be my guest, it’s your money. However,
for the ABKCO years you might consider the alternative of The Rolling Stones In Mono. Unfortunately it does duplicate some
tracks by including both the US and UK versions of Out Of Our Heads and Aftermath
and includes the US only album Flowers.
But you’ll get everything ABKCO controls up after 2009, when several songs
[notably Brown Sugar and Wild Horses] reverted back to the band.
From personal experience, just like the Beatles catalog up through Rubber Soul, I find the Stones catalog
in mono a little more satisfying than the sometimes weird stereo mixes
[especially weird and uneven on Between
the Buttons!].
** My Uncle J. Michael
Leone, God rest his soul, used to tell me that Ron Wood was “absolutely the
worst choice” the Stones could have made to replace Mick Taylor. In a way, I
get that – Ron Wood as a lead guitar player is not in the same class as Mick Taylor.
However, Mick Taylor was not the kind of guitar player who really “meshed” with
Keith Richards. Coming from being the lead and rhythm guitarist for the Faces,
Ronnie would just switch between the two as the song needed. I think that this
wall of guitars where you don’t know who played what [and Keith says sometimes they
don’t either] allowed him to move around the rhythm as well instead of being
forced to anchor it at all times. SOME people have called Ron Wood a “Keith
Clone.” My take on it is that Ron Wood can play like Keith but Keith can’t play
like Ronnie.

