Random Record Revisited:
The Roaring Silence – Manfred Mann’s Earth Band
[1976]
When Manfred Mann’s Earth Band’s version of Blinded By
the Light popped up on the radio it was like nothing else out there. It was
one of those songs that forced you to sit on the station that just played it or
go hopping around the dial looking for it on another station. The single
version at 3:49 cuts out three minutes of jamming in the middle [a cardinal sin
of say the Knack’s My Sharona single] yet still feels like it captures
the complete spirit of the song.
Blinded kicks off MMEB’s The Roaring Silence
in high cotton. Unfortunately, the second track Singing The Dolphin Through
is an overlong, slow mid-tempo thing that rises and swells like parts of Styx’s
Come Sail Away melded with the Monkees’ The Porpoise Song. After
about five and a half minutes it falls into the prog death spiral of guitar
solo over fanfare keyboards then a descending synthesizer figure that leads to
calm, lolling waves over which someone has now decided to add some honking
saxophone solo. [To say I am not a fan of this song would be a pretty fair
statement.] And then surprisingly, the next cut Waiter, There’s A Yawn In My
Ear kicks into some interesting keyboard runs and riffs that turn into an
interesting instrumental jam. It's nothing to challenge a band like Yes but it
avoids being just stock, dull “rock by numbers.” Applause at the end indicates
that this may be something cut off a live tape.
The second side is actually pretty darn good. The Road To
Babylon is some good light prog with a choir and some time shifts. Good
wah-wah lead work by Chris Hamlet Thompson. Hate the abrupt cut off that ends
the song. My copy is the second issue of the album which has a touched up recording
of another Bruce song, Spirits In the Night with vocals by new singer Thompson. [A
longer version of Spirits had been on the band’s previous album Nightingales
And Bombers. It featured a stretched out middle section with some tasty
work by Mick Rogers which probably heavily inspired what was to come with Blinded.]
This heavily edited version is nowhere
near as interesting. This Side Of Paradise cops the vocal melody from Brandy You’re A Fine Girl but puts it over a bubbling light progressive
tune. Starbird has a bit of uptempo jamming ala Led Boots on Jeff Beck’s Wired
that breaks into a little chordal dirge at the end akin to something maybe the
Alan Parsons Project would be doing on I, Robot. Questions is not
a cover of the Moody Blues but flows similarly like a Moody Blues song with
Brian May adding a fanfare like solo.
As a second-tier progressive band album, I find Manfred Mann’s
Earth Band satisfying enough to warrant digging up a couple more albums to see
if there’s another good record out there.
ADDENDA: Apparently the remastered CD version puts the touched
up Spirits In the Night after Questions and adds the single
version of BBtL as the final cut. Maybe this original running order which
appears on the first pressing [denoted by its sepia brown colored jacket, not
the blue green one] might be a little more satisfying than the one with Spirits
plopped down [possibly breaking the cosmic flow]between Babylon and Paradise.
And one review says Singing the Dolphin Through is a cover of Mike Heron
who was also in the Incredible String Band. This does not change my opinion of
the Earth Band’s cut here, I add it merely to be informative.