The Day After: The FalloutFrom today's
Fort Worth Star Telegram lead:
Darryl Sydor, then a defenseman for the Stars, sat at his locker after practice, contemplating the specter of an unprecedented labor dispute on the horizon. "They're going to cancel the season," he concluded. That was more than three years ago.
But for those three years, "Cancel the Season" was regarded as mostly battle cry rhetoric between the NHL and the NHL Players' Association. "I don't think we ever thought it would really happen," Stars center Mike Modano said.As a fan I am pissed off about this [you may have guessed], but I said all along that ownership was right on this. View my October archive, specifically
My $ 1.25 Rant/Opinion on the NHL Lockout. I still can't believe the players didn't think it would happen. How long did they think the owners would wait?
I heard Barry Melrose on ESPN Radio this morning saying he had players calling him all night begging him to contact [NHLPA President] Trevor Linden and see if a deal can be struck for a 45 million dollar cap. And he said he was told over and over: "
We NEVER THOUGHT they would cancel the season."
Well boo-hoo players. I guess we know which side is serious now. You stupid fucks. You think this is game? What you do on the ice is a game. This is about the long term survival of the NHL. What part of "Now is not the time to begging negotiating" did Bob Goodenow tell you wasn't serious? Did you think the deadline was a fucking bluff? Guess your pair of deuces weren't a winning hand...
I ask again where were Mario and Wayne in all this? I see this on
The Hockey News page:
I
t's not just the fans who think it was crazy the way the 2004-05 NHL season was canceled. According to two separate sources, Wayne Gretzky and Mario Lemieux have re-entered the picture in an attempt to get the season back on track. "I was told Gretzky and Lemieux got involved, to try to talk some sense into the (union) executive committee," the source said. "A lot of people who care about the game say they're too close not to at least talk some more." However, Gretzky downplayed his involvement during a radio interview with the Fan 590 in Toronto. "To say Mario and I had a conversation to stir up the conversations and talks again, that's just not true," Gretzky said. Veteran players are believed to be involved in a movement to resurrect the season. One source said many veteran players called NHL commissioner Gary Bettman directly since the cancellation announcement Wednesday afternoon.
IF this is all true, then you've just seen NHLPA Union exec Bob Goodenow's arms chopped off. The Hockey News describes the negotiations as the famous Black Knight scene in Monty Python and the Holy Grail: 'You've got no arms left." "It's just a flesh wound."
In the Fort Worth Star Telegram, hockey writer Mac Engle noted:
But some players now say that a salary cap is inevitable.
"I think so, now," Modano said. "I'm not sure why [it was offered]. I was upset that for three years [the union] has been explaining to us with diagram after diagram why a cap isn't good, and then they propose it. "I think all along [the league] was trying to get some adversity between us [the players] with name calling, and they have succeeded a little bit. There were a lot of internal things going on; players were rumored to be calling the league pushing for a cap. I believe that happened."
Some players say that the union will rally, however, because the players do not believe the owners report revenues honestly and because of their almost unanimous contempt for Bettman.
No fragmentation has surfaced publicly among the owners.
"We're trapped," Carolina Hurricanes owner Peter Karmanos said. "That's why we have 30 owners that are lined up and saying we're going to lose a whole season and maybe another one and maybe another one after that. Maybe only 5,000 people will show up at our games. But we won't be losing a billion dollars a season. "The problem is that, in every pro sport, the owners are going to have to dig their heels in the sand and say enough is enough," Karmanos added. "I have a feeling that fans of every sport are fed up with the salaries and the attitudes and the steroids and the brawls and the criminal records and the total detachment from reality. Our hockey players are head and shoulders better people, but I believe the problem in the end is the same. They've lost touch with reality."
That's it folks! The owners win. They split the players and now they divide and conquer. But I think ownership knows now that they have to work WITH the players to keep the league viable. As Engle pointed out in another spot, owners looking for NFL riches and NFL salary caps had better start sharing revenue like NFL owners. Look for a cap eventually tied to income, but it;s going to require gives elsewhere, like earlier free agency.
Elsewhere in today's
Startlegram, columnist Jim Reeves has this to say; I think he summed it all up very nicely:
I was listening to a sports talk show discussion this week about who's to blame for this situation, the players or the owners, and my first thought was, "Who cares?"
Who to blame isn't really the point, is it? Yes, the owners did this to themselves by overpaying the players. They can't help themselves. They need a system that keeps them from hurting themselves.
When you've just been told you have cancer, it doesn't really matter so much any more how it happened; it only matters that you get treatment.In some ways, a conclusion to the stalemate is a relief.
"Thank goodness we're no longer lobbing grenades from Toronto and New York," Stars president Jim Lites said. "If it's about the money, we'll get it done. We're a million miles closer than we were.
"Hopefully, with the hyperbole and the demagoguery aside, at least this process will gain some momentum. If we'd been this close last May, this would have gotten done."
The bottom line is that the NHL was on its way to economic ruin. The game was becoming too rich for the country where it was born. It needs big-time restructuring, not just economically, but on the ice, too.
It doesn't matter who's responsible for this problem; it only matters that it's fixed.
That's why a salary cap is the only answer for the NHL, and even the players' association finally understood that and shocked many of its members by finally agreeing in the wee hours Tuesday morning to accept something it said it would never accept.
Not 48 hours earlier, Stars forward Bill Guerin, a players' association vice president, was stupidly saying, "We would rather fold the league than accept a salary cap."
Union leader Bob Goodenow then made Guerin look like a fool by agreeing to accept a cap.
"To turn around and actually propose it ourselves bothered a lot of guys," Stars center Mike Modano admitted during a radio interview Wednesday. "We could have done that in August. There's certainly going to be some upset guys.
After all that time of saying, 'No, no, no,' then saying yes, it defeated the whole purpose of what we were trying to accomplish."
Like almost every sports-labor negotiation, this one didn't really get serious until it was too late.
"We got more done on the 15th of February than we did in talking about it for a year," Lites pointed out. "We can't have that kind of gonzo negotiating and get this done in five minutes. We can't pull a Hail Mary."
The hope now is that the disillusioned players will use their last-minute concession as a basis to forge a new agreement. The union stunningly agreed to accept a $49 million cap, something that should have happened weeks, if not months, ago. The owners removed any linkage to revenues and offered a $42 million cap.
"
If we'd started this kind of negotiating months ago, we wouldn't be talking about it now," Modano said. "Now, you're talking about a $ 61/2 million difference between us and them. If we gave three and they gave back three, now we're at $46 million and we could possibly open up training camp next week. Instead, we have a lost season over 6 million bucks."
Modano himself is losing $9 million this season.
"Changing the concept was the hard part," he said. "Now it's just going back and forth over numbers, that's the easy part."
Maybe not. NHL commissioner Gary Bettman insists the league offer is now off the table, and the work starts all over again.
It's up to owners like the Stars' Tom Hicks to force Bettman back to the negotiating table immediately.
"
Now that we've broken the psychological barrier of the union's opposition to a cap, like it was some sort of bad disease, we have to take advantage and find something that's fair for both sides." Hicks said. "I'd love to have a deal done before the first of June so we can spend the rest of the summer re-launching the sport. I think the near-miss has people on both sides saying if we'd had more time we might could have made this work. There's absolutely no reason to wait and start all over again next fall."
It's not all about economics, either. It's about changing the game on the ice to make it more appealing to fans, too.
"The NHL and players, on different occasions, have both talked a lot about things that would enhance the game both on and off ice, like shootouts [instead of tie games], which I think ultimately will happen," Stars coach Dave Tippett said. "Does our game have to step out of the box and start looking at some of these things? Certainly it does."
Fans would have seen some of those changes immediately in a condensed season, Bettman said as he announced that the 2004-05 season had been taken off life support and officially declared dead.
"We had planned two scenarios for this press conference," Bettman said. "The other would have included a laundry list of rules changes that we could have used in a short season. We would have had a couple of months to test some things and evaluate them over the summer. We have collectively -- the league and the players' association -- squandered an opportunity to move forward."
The players blame the owners. The owners blame the players. The players are mad at each other. The one thing everyone agrees on is that they all blame Bettman, who seems intent on crushing the union, even if means resorting to replacement players next season.
Somehow, within all these raging emotions, someone must inject some common sense and start negotiating right now to save the 2005-06 season before it's lost, too.
"We need to get this done right now," Lites said. "We need to find middle ground. I'm less concerned about the numbers in a cap than in how it works."
Said Bettman: "The shame of this is, our fans deserve better, the people who earn their livelihood in this game deserve better. We're going to have to earn back the trust and the love and affection of everybody associated with the game."
That won't be easy. This isn't Major League Baseball, or the NFL, or even the NBA, mainstream professional sports that are entrenched as part of the American psyche. But it's also not impossible, because hockey really is a great game.
I do miss it, but it can be made better.
"It's like a stock-market correction," Tippett said. "We're undergoing a big one. We'll fix it. We'll come back, stronger and better than we were before."
That's a promise that both sides must vow to keep.