So I was watching Color Me Obsessed, last night [instead of lie sleeping or something important like that.] It's the 2011 film [meaning there's not even a hint of the Filthy Luchre Reunion shows] of fans and critics talking about how the Replacements were the greatest "____" band .
It made me think about my own fandom of the Replacements. I am one of the rare birds - a fan of the later Replacements albums.
I guess I was too old to "punk" by the time I found Sorry Ma... Hootenany has a few moments but is mostly forgotten. Let It Be is a good album although Favorite Thing and We're Coming Out have not held up well. Tim is only moves me half the time - Bastards and Hold My Life, of course. Swingin' Party and Left Of the Dial. It's been in and out of my collection a couple of times [currently: out]. And it sounds like it was recorded with a blanket in front of the microphones. But the last two? HUGE fan. I used to have Don't Tell A Soul and All Shook Down Back To Back [see what I did there?] on a 90 minute cassette and I would play it over and over and over for a week at a time, back when I was in Burleson and I had to drive at least 20 minutes to get anywhere. When I was driving 45 minutes to an hour each way to get from Burleson to downtown Dallas five days a week.
My introduction to the band was 1987's Pleased To Meet Me. [And I might not have ever heard that had I not been working in a record store. But I did and I fell [mostly] in love. Nightclub Jitters still doesn't do anything for me. The Ledge moves the needle a bit but not much.] Since this was my introduction to the band, I had no idea about the politics going on over recent releases, the firing of Bob Stinson or even what the band sounded like before this release. Therefore, I was not appalled by the use of horns or strings or acoustic guitars or any of the things that offended "original band" or "from the start" Replacements fans. I'm pretty sure I didn't know about the Twin Tone releases until the Inconcerated EP brought Answering Machine and Here Comes A Regular into my orbit. [I didn't know Another Girl, Another Planet was a cover either until many years later when I heard the original.]
That opening salvo of I.O.U, Alex Chilton and I Don't Know though - FUCKING FANTASTIC. That whole second side smokes and then suddenly there's the super quiet Skyway. And then the sheer brilliance of Can't Hardly Wait - which if it isn't my favorite Replacements song most days, it's surely top three. [You know what makes it such a great song - besides that riff? It's the breaks - the skidding to a dead stop for two bars. It gives you a second to absorb what you've heard - and a second to anticipate everything kicking back in again. And those horns. Just like Jim Price and Bobby Keys on Exile On Main Street - they give it just a touch of soul, just a punch to put it over the top.]
Since I joined the party so late, I also didn't know to be horrified by the purely poptasticness [po + fantastic = poptastic] of Don't Tell A Soul. Maybe the first couple of times I tracked it I was "Boy this sure doesn't sound much like the last record" but I soon fell in love with it for a different reason. It could rock some [I'll Be You, I Won't, Back To Back, We'll Inherit the Earth] but when they slowed down the wrote some really pretty songs. I was 21 when I got Pleased To Meet Me - Paul Westerberg would have been 29. Staring 30 in the eyeballs, he could have been asking himself "Do I want to be caught up playing some cartoonish over the top boob when I'm 30 or 35 like the god damn Ramones? Or do I want to say something?" Hearing DTAS, I think he wanted to say something. He did say something to me. Don't Tell A Soul touched me in a way that's hard to explain. Part of it was the times - the people I was running with, the girl I was hopelessly head over heels for. The moments it seemed we were together and the sudden "we have to talk" and "losing" what you never really "had." [But that doesn't really mean anything when your heart is dedicated.] I found a lot of solace in Achin' To Be and They're Blind and Darlin' One. Many nights achin' to be on her canvas. Many nights pondering the things I held dearly that were judged once and then swept aside.
Then came All Shook Down. The ridiculously low selling finale, the all but in name Paul Westerberg solo debut. People hate and loathe this record and I don't get it. It's not that far removed from Don't Tell A Soul which sold a respectable 300,000 copies. I guess if you were a fan of a certain narrow form of expression like 2 minute bursts of energy of Sorry Ma, then All Shook Down [and Don't Tell A Soul] are complete "sell out" records. "What, they want to be pop stars, have hits and get played on the radio? Fuck that noise!" But then, Let It Be would be a sell out record too. Too polished and professional sounding. But I like it. It continues the slide to mainstream but on the Replacements own terms. Merry Go Round, One Wink At A Time, Nobody and When It Began are pretty good "Pop" [as in Popular] songs but they have those weird little bits that are pure 'Mats. The guitar solo on Nobody - the song kind of a winking tip of the hat to I Knew the Bride When She Used to Rock & Roll - is just too weird to be on top 40 radio. Otherwise it's a great dose of power pop. the lines in One Wink At A Time ["The magazine she flips through / is the special double issue / smells like perfume / she leaves it on the plane"] don't fit anyone's play list. I love the line in Bent Out Of Shape: "A little sleepy time tea / spiked with a heartache."
But the killer here is the worldy weary Sadly Beautiful. I don't have the words to describe the emotions this brings up. Open to interpretation of course, it seems to be about someone admired from far away who only occasionally crosses your path but each time they do, you notice them slipping into some sort of darkness that they finally give into [Think No Place From You from 2002's Stereo] or succumb to.
The "second side" [i.e. everything after When It Began] starts really getting a little weird. but on cassette, 70 MPH on a darkened interstate, you're committed. Plus it's not BAD, just weird short little things. Happy Town is a little slice of Pleasant Valley Sunday [lyrically] run through Westerberg. Maybe a warning to the bands following - attention Goo Goo Dolls! The duet with Concrete Blonde's Johnette Napolitano [My Little Problem] is a hot little rocker.
As far as the movie, well, it was interesting hearing how the Replacements impacted some people. I guess they had an impact on me as well but not to a fanatical level. I never saw The Replacements, though I have seen Replacements -Westerberg once, Tommy twice [once solo and one with the short lived Bash & Pop] even short set by Bob 'Slim' Dunlap. I still enjoy putting those records on from time to time but I admit Bash & Pop's Friday Night Is Killing Me is the one I've probably played the most in the last decade. [I had that on a cassette with Izzy Stradlin & the Juju Hounds - another one that I could play over and over.]